The High Points
- Cats are carnivores and were never meant to eat high carbohydrate diets
- Commercial diets -- especially dry diets -- are too high in carbohydrates
- Many cats need more water in their diet than they will voluntarily drink, and dry diets aggravate that problem
- Dry diets are not that helpful in preventing dental disease
- Experts are beginning to warn against feeding cats dry diets
- If your cat is addicted to dry food or is picky, it is important to make changes carefully -- don’t let your cat stop eating in protest
Dry food is best, right?
Dry pet food is a dehydrated mix of grains, meats, and added vitamins and minerals. Dry foods are typically 30-60% carbohydrate in composition. What isn’t well known among cat owners is that a requirement for carbohydrates has never been proven in the cat (in contrast to dogs and people). Cats are carnivores, and in the wild, eat nothing but meaty little rodents, bugs, birds and lizards. Our domesticated cats, on the other hand, are fed mixtures of meat and grain that produce a balanced diet over the long term. Many believe that those grains, aside from providing 'artificial' balance, may be contributing to problems in the long run.
Look, my cat is doing well on dry food. Why should I change?
Cats descend from desert animals that depended on their food to provide needed water. Their kidneys are adapted to this desert environment to conserve water and concentrate the wastes into the urine. When cats don’t get enough water from food or additional water intake, some feel that cats spend much of their lives chronically dehydrated, which is not good for those kidneys or the rest of the body.
One common problem that seems to respond to more water in the food is the very frustrating FUS, now called FLUTD (Lower urinary tract disease). Many doctors recommend feeding canned food only to these cats, to increase water going into the body and out through the bladder. Could this be a signal that cats don’t do well on dry food?
Also, many people tend to leave dry food out all the time, leaving their cats to 'free feed’. As convenient as it may be, this is a potentially harmful practice for the cat! Most cats given food all the time eat more than they should, and this is what is behind a growing epidemic of obese cats. And no, it doesn’t usually work to give them weight loss food free choice!
In addition, free feeding these high carbohydrate meals has been suggested to contribute to the rising incidence of diabetes in cats (Rand, 1998). Since this is a chronic, potentially dangerous problem requiring sometimes-lifelong insulin injections, this is a major concern.
Finally, many people have difficulty medicating their cats, and are forced to mix it in food. It’s much easier to mix medicine in canned food than in dry food. Cats who are addicted to dry food and won’t eat any canned food (a common problem) are a special challenge to medicate!
But I was always told to leave food out all the time. Doesn’t this decrease urine pH and prevent lower urinary tract disease? It is true that eating small meals often lowers urinary pH. And cats are born to hunt constantly, catching little protein meals throughout the day. Remember, though, that dry food is not a meat protein like a lizard or mouse, and since it contains large amounts of carbohydrates (and often less fat) than real prey, we are essentially turning our cats into grazers. Worse, hunting cats are expending mental and physical activity between kills, and must work hard for those meals. The only exercise our dry food 'grazers' are often getting is a jump off the couch!
OK, but what about my cat’s teeth? Isn’t canned food bad for them?
Scientific evidence does say that cats eating canned food have worse teeth than cats eating dry food, however, if dry food were all that effective, we would not be seeing the large number of ‘dental’ diets recently introduced to the market. Saying that dry cat food is great at preventing dental disease is like claiming that people could eat pretzels to maintain their teeth! Teeth need proper nutrition (good quality diets increase all-around health and decrease susceptibility to gum disease), exercise (dental toys or safe meaty bones act like dental floss!), and preventive treatment (brushing, where possible)
Well, maybe so, but I can’t get my cat to eat anything new!
Well, this is a problem. Cats easily become addicted to certain types of foods. Like people who become addicted to cigarettes or drugs, this isn’t always good for them. A cat willing to eat only one kind of food will be much more difficult to support nutritionally when s/he gets sick and we are forced to feed them something different! In addition, recent findings by some feline veterinarians suggest that this feeding practice offering only one kind of food for years on end actually contributes to the development of food allergies in cats (or inflammatory bowel disease, which is often synonymous).
We recommend that all cats have a rotating diet, changing food types and food brands 2-4 times yearly. Cats are sometimes willing to go along with you on this, but if not, don’t force the issue by starving the cat. Cats that don’t eat are susceptible to a serious disease called fatty liver syndrome (hepatic lipidosis), which is a potentially fatal liver condition. If your cat is resistant to change, gradually try this technique.
- If free feeding, gradually reduce the availability of the food so that the cat is finishing what s/he is offered during two meal times during the day. In other words, if food is usually available 24 hours daily, make it available for 4 hours in the morning and 4 hours at night, then 2 hours in the morning and 2 at night, and finally for only 1 hour each time. Make sure to call your cat to meals so that s/he does not miss the opportunity to learn that a meal is available during set times of the day.
- Once you have turned your free feeder into a meal feeder, start mixing the new food into the old food. If your cat isn’t interested, stop mixing the new food in and return to the old food.
- Cut the amount of old food by 1/2 for ONLY 1 day. Your cat should become fairly hungry by the second day. This is when s/he is motivated to try the new taste, and you can once again begin mixing in the new food, very little at first and gradually increasing the amount.
Remember that the object is to increase your cat’s motivation to try something new without starving him or her. DONT let your cat lose weight, and don’t push the issue too hard some cats would rather get sick than switch. It’s best to work with your veterinarian’s scale during this process.
The advantages to changing your cat’s eating habits are many-fold. By switching from free feeding dry food to meal feeding canned with some dry, you can more easily control the amount and kind of food your cat gets. Cats fed this way are usually not as addicted to a single type of food, and rotating the diet will become much less stressful. And by rotating the diet, you will learn what foods your cat looks and feels best on. If your cat refuses to switch easily using the technique above, go ahead and give in, but keep thinking about how your next cat will be fed!Go back